UK Nonlinear
News,
August 1999
Introduction to Wave Propagation in Nonlinear Fluids and Solids
By D.S. Drumheller
Reviewed by Dr
Penny Davies (Department of Mathematics, University of
Strathclyde)
Published by Cambridge University
Press, 1998
Paperback: ISBN 0 521 58746 8 (cost: £29.95)
Hardback: ISBN 0 521 58313 6 (cost: £80.00)
This book is described as a comprehensive introductory text on stress
waves in nonlinear materials (both fluids and solids), and is aimed at
advanced undergraduate or graduate students (and also as a reference
for engineers and applied physicists). It contains five chapters and
two appendices. Chapter 0 gives an overview of the rest of the book,
and also describes two classical one dimensional (1D) experiments - the
shock tube and flyer plate - that introduce the concepts of shock,
rarefaction and structured waves. These experiments are revisited at
points throughout the book.
Chapter 1 is devoted to kinematics and balance laws. Both the material
(Lagrangian) and spatial (Eulerian) descriptions are used to derive the
conservation laws of mass and momentum, firstly in 1D and then in 3D.
In Chapter 2 a purely mechanical theory of waves in elastic materials
is developed. The chapter opens with definitions and properties of
elastic materials, and then goes on to discuss 1D nonlinear elastic
wave equations (briefly) and 1D linear elastic waves (in detail). The
theory of Riemann invariants is introduced to solve the linear wave
equations (method of characteristics), and this is then generalised to
Riemann integral solutions of the nonlinear equations. The chapter
continues with sections on 1D structured (continuous) and shock
(discontinuous) acoustic waves in nonlinear materials and wave-wave
interactions. It concludes with a discussion of the book's key
concept, namely that although smooth compressive acoustic waves in
nonlinear elastic materials (mathematically) develop shocks, in fact
shock waves do not exist in real materials. This apparent
paradox is overcome by using thermoelastic rather than purely elastic
constitutive models, and the next chapter is devoted to developing the
theory of thermodynamics.
At the start of Chapter 3 Drumheller explains that when accurate
experimental measurements are taken, waves in real elastic materials
that appear to be shocks are found in fact to be continuous. This is
because the waves cause changes in temperature as they pass through the
material (as well as altering the stress) and some of the wave energy
is absorbed by the material. This chapter mainly considers 1D
deformations (although the 3D energy balance equation is also derived),
and contains derivations of 1D constitutive laws for viscous,
thermoelastic and thermoviscous materials using the second law of
thermodynamics or Clausius-Duhem inequality. Types of solutions of the
resulting equations that preserve various quantities (entropy,
temperature, pressure, etc.) are discussed in detail.
The final chapter considers some more specific constitutive models
(ideal gases and Mie-Grueneisen solids), and also considers
elasto-plastic materials, porous solids, detonation and phase
transformations. The appendices are devoted to numerical methods for
solving linear and nonlinear wave equations (A), and tables of material
constants (B).
As a non-thermodynamicist who has taught an honours course on continuum
mechanics, I found aspects of this book interesting. I had not
appreciated that shock waves are a mathematical approximation to what
happens in practice, caused by using an incomplete set of constitutive
equations. (Or equivalently that elastic waves cause oscillations in
temperature as well as stress.) I also enjoyed some of the author's
historical observations, and applaud his decision to include a modern
derivation of various constitutive laws in detail using the second law
of thermodynamics. I would however have some reservations (detailed
below) both in using this book as a basis for teaching a course or in
recommending it as a professional reference.
- Notation
This is both complicated and somewhat imprecise. The "summation
convention" (that repeated indices in an expression are summed) is used
when dealing with 3D motions, which is an elegant and precise way of
presenting the equations. However the author uses it in combination
with a componentwise notation for vectors and tensors which can be
misleading. For example, instead of showing the dependence of the
deformation x on the material point X
and time t by writing x =
x(X,t), the author instead uses the notation x_k
= x_k(X_m,t). This is not technically correct since the component
x_k of the deformation depends on all components of
X and not just on the component X_m.
- Definitions
Imprecision also extends to a few of the basic definitions in the book,
in a way that might be confusing to those who have not encountered the
concepts before. For example, a distinction is not made between
independent and dependent variables in the definition of a linear
equation, and an elastic material is defined to be one for which the
stress is only a function of the deformation gradient, when this is
actually a homogeneous elastic material (the stress in an
elastic material can also depend on the material point
X).
- 3D vs. 1D
Although I can understand why the author may have decided to restrict
the text to mainly 1D deformations and wave solutions I think that his
way of doing so could be misleading. I have particular problems with
Chapter 3 in which the 1D character of the solution is essentially
imposed as a constitutive requirement in the derivation of constitutive
laws for viscous and thermal materials, and think that the text would
be much improved by considering 3D constitutive laws and balance
equations and then reducing them to 1D in order to look at wave
solutions. A full 3D derivation is fundamentally more complicated than
the material presented here (it would involve regarding the principle
of frame indifference as an identity as well as the Clausius-Duhem
inequality), but to my mind the resulting theory is clearer and much
more satisfying (see e.g. the derivation of purely mechanical
constitutive laws in [1]).
- References
One of the main drawbacks in the use of this book by professionals is
its extremely short reference section. Only 31 references are listed,
and of these fewer than 10 date since 1980 (although some additional
references are given as footnotes scattered throughout the text). The
book would greatly benefit by having many more pointers to related
books and papers, so the interested reader could use it to navigate
his/her way through some of the more modern developments in rational
mechanics and thermodynamics. As an example, at one point in Chapter 3
Drumheller says that the reader would find it rewarding to consult some
of the work on entropy in the kinetic theory of gases, without listing
a single source! Other obvious references that should have been
included are [2] in the section on Riemann invariants and some good
numerical analysis texts (see below).
- Numerical solution
Appendix A (Numerical methods) contains a description of some common
schemes (basically all leapfrog methods, although they're not described
as such) for solving the linear and nonlinear elastic wave equations. I
found this section quite confusing -- the emphasis on the underlying
physics often obscured the detail of the numerical approximations. To
my mind it would have been better to restrict this section to writing
the wave equation in standard first order form, listing some popular
solution schemes (by name), and giving some good numerical analysis
references both for students and practising engineers or scientists
(like [3-5]). As it is, fundamentally important concepts like
stability are touched on but not described very clearly, and someone
reading about numerical methods for the first time is likely to emerge
from this section thinking that the CFL condition and von Neumann
stability are one and the same.
References
- M.E. Gurtin, An Introduction to Continuum Mechanics
(Academic Press, 1981).
- P.D. Lax, Hyperbolic Systems of Conservation Laws and the
Mathematical Theory of Shock Waves (SIAM, 1973).
- R.J. Leveque, Numerical methods for conservation laws (2nd
ed., Birkhauser, 1992).
- A.R. Mitchell & D.F. Griffiths, The Finite Difference Method
in Partial Differential Equations (Wiley, 1980).
- K.W. Morton & D.F. Mayers, Numerical solution of partial
differential equations (CUP, 1994).
UK Nonlinear News thanks
Cambridge University Press
for providing a copy of this book for review.
<< Move to UK Nonlinear News Issue
Seventeen Index Page
(August 1999).
15/06/99 (PJD)
Last Updated: 16th June 1999.
uknonl@amsta.leeds.ac.uk.